Pendlebury Set to Exit
· news
The Pendlebury-Howe Conundrum: When Greatness Meets Reality
The Collingwood Magpies are at a crossroads, facing a decision that will have far-reaching consequences for their future on and off the field. As the 2027 season approaches, the club must grapple with the impending retirements of Scott Pendlebury and Jeremy Howe. Both men have given their all to the Magpies, but only one can stay.
Collingwood has long been built around a core group of veterans who led the team to premiership glory. However, as seasons pass, it’s clear that this era is coming to an end. The club’s management must weigh up the pros and cons of retaining each player, considering their contributions, contract status, and the needs of the team.
In recent weeks, a scenario has emerged suggesting only one of Pendlebury or Howe will wear the Magpies’ guernsey in 2027. While both players have been stalwarts for the club, it’s evident that Collingwood is looking to the future. In an era where regeneration is crucial, the Magpies must carefully manage their list to ensure a smooth transition.
Pendlebury, the AFL games record holder and one of Collingwood’s immortals, has been a cornerstone of the team for over two decades. However, his performances have declined in recent seasons, raising questions about his ability to continue at the highest level. Despite being an exceptional thinker on the field, his body may not be able to keep up with the demands of AFL football.
Jeremy Howe, on the other hand, has been a revelation in 2025, displaying remarkable form and vision on the field. His ability to read the game and capitalize on opportunities is unmatched, making him an invaluable asset to the Magpies. With his contract set to expire, it’s unclear whether Collingwood will opt to retain him.
The decision to let one of these legends go will be a difficult one for the club’s management. Both players have given so much to the Magpies over the years, and their contributions cannot be overstated. Yet, in the grand scheme of things, it’s essential that the club prioritize its future success.
The arrival of Lachie Neale has added complexity to the situation. If Collingwood can secure his services, they will need to create space on the list for him to thrive. This may mean making tough decisions about who to keep and who to let go, including one of their most revered players.
In this sense, the Pendlebury-Howe conundrum is not just a matter of individual talent or team dynamics – it’s also about the bigger picture. As Collingwood looks to rebuild its list and provide opportunities for younger players, it must be ruthless in its decision-making. Only by doing so can they ensure a bright future on the field.
The signs are already pointing towards a one-club career for Scott Pendlebury, who has spoken about his love for the Magpies and his desire to remain part of their fabric. While this is admirable, it’s essential that he understands the club’s needs come first.
Jeremy Howe, however, has options open to him. As a veteran with exceptional coaching acumen, he could potentially join another club or take up a role in coaching. This would be a shame for Collingwood fans, who have grown to love his quirky personality and remarkable talent.
As the Magpies prepare to make their decision, one thing is clear: only one of these two legends can stay. It’s a cruel reality that will test the club’s resolve and its commitment to building a brighter future. The Sherrin is in Collingwood’s court – and theirs alone.
Reader Views
- EKEditor K. Wells · editor
It's time for Collingwood to acknowledge the pendulum has swung on Pendlebury and Howe. While both are legends in their own right, retaining one at the expense of the other is a gut-wrenching decision that will test the club's priorities. The article correctly notes the importance of regeneration, but it glosses over the financial implications of such a move. If Collingwood chooses to release Pendlebury and retain Howe, they'll be taking on significant contract commitments while shedding experienced leadership. A more nuanced discussion about the club's budget would provide a clearer understanding of their decision-making process.
- RJReporter J. Avery · staff reporter
The Pendlebury conundrum highlights the cruel realities of football's fleeting nature. Collingwood's loyalty is admirable, but the club must acknowledge that Pendlebury's time is up. His decline in performance has been evident for seasons, and his body can't keep pace with the demands of the game. The question now is what to do with Jeremy Howe, who represents a vital link between the old guard and the next generation of Magpies. Retaining him would be a savvy move, but it's also a calculated risk given his contract status – Collingwood must carefully weigh the financial implications before making a decision.
- CSCorrespondent S. Tan · field correspondent
The Pendlebury-Howe conundrum is ultimately about more than just two players - it's a litmus test for Collingwood's commitment to regeneration and a genuine willingness to let go of yesterday's heroes. While Scott Pendlebury's on-field decline has been well-documented, the Magpies must consider whether his influence in the locker room is enough to justify retaining him over Jeremy Howe, who has shown remarkable form but still has one year left on his contract. One thing's for certain - whatever decision they make, it won't be easy for either party involved.